Skip to main content

← About Helikon Labs

Research · Cross-cutting

Catalyzing Strategic Partnerships: Digital Transformation of University-Industry Collaborations for Synchronized Innovation

Andrew T. Flowers and Rebecca Roadman Presented at the R&D Management Conference 2024, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, 17 to 19 June 2024 (conference page) Download the paper (PDF, free) The paper as presented at the conference, reformatted by Helikon Labs. 13 pages. © 2024 Andrew T. Flowers and Rebecca Roadman. Licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0: free to share for noncommercial use, with credit to the authors and without changes.

What the paper asked

University-industry research collaborations run on a long chain of work: finding a partner, agreeing the terms, running the project, and deciding what comes next. By 2024 there was software for almost every link in that chain, yet the collaborations were still slow and hard to run. The paper asked two questions:

  • What are the key inefficiencies and challenges in the collaboration lifecycle of university-industry partnerships, and how has digital transformation contributed to these frictions?
  • How can collaborative digital ecosystems help address these frictions to improve technology commercialization and innovation outcomes?

How the study worked

It's an exploratory study, built in three parts.

A framework. The authors started from RAND's commercial technology pipeline for defense innovation (Kotila et al. 2023) and the strategic-alliance lifecycle work of Kale and Singh (2009) and Hoang and Rothaermel (2016). From these they built a university-industry commercial technology pipeline, the UI-CTP. It has four phases: partner and technology selection, alliance formation, execution and governance, and evaluation and exit.

A faculty survey. After background conversations with university and industry experts, the authors surveyed faculty at five public research universities in the eastern and midwestern United States. They chose fields with a high propensity to partner with industry: biology, chemical engineering, chemistry, materials science, economics, and environmental science. The survey went to 801 faculty, from assistant professors and department chairs to named professors, and only a small share responded. That's far too few for statistical inference, which the paper says plainly. The point was exploration.

A market assessment. The authors sorted the software on the market into five categories: innovation management platforms, customer relationship management, project and portfolio management, contract lifecycle management, and knowledge management. They mapped each one against the activities in the UI-CTP. Then they ran a gap analysis between the tools faculty reported using and what the framework needs.

What it found

  • Most respondents had worked on university-industry partnerships, and most wanted more of them. Their interest tracked how simple, effective, and clear the process was.
  • Intellectual property disputes and breakdowns in contract negotiation were the challenges respondents described most often.
  • Personal connections were the most common way respondents had found their industry partners. Formal routes through the university came well behind.
  • Researchers mostly aren't involved in negotiating the contract. Institutional legal and contract teams generally handle it, in their own silo.
  • The tools in use were general-purpose. Email, office software, and general search tools did most of the work. In the paper's words, processes were "adapted around the proliferation of common digital tools, such as desktop applications and email ... rather than strategically designed to optimize the collaborative innovation process."
  • Each software category covers part of the lifecycle, and none covers all of it. The gap analysis found the tools in use "insufficient in satisfying all needs" of the pipeline. The authors called for shared digital collaboration platforms that cross organizational boundaries while keeping trust and security requirements intact.
  • The low response rate was itself informative. The authors read it as a possible sign of unfamiliarity with industry partnership opportunities, or of faculty not seeing industry partnership as part of their role.

What it doesn't show

The survey is small and exploratory. Its respondents are faculty only, so the paper speaks to the university side of the collaboration, not the company side. It covers five public research universities in one region and a handful of fields, in 2024. The authors flag the next steps themselves: other fields (computer science and the health sciences among them), more institutions and regions, and the special case of collaborating with small and medium businesses.

Why it matters to Helikon Labs

This paper is where Helikon Labs started. The UI-CTP framework it introduced became the Helikon Method, the four-phase framework we work from today: Match, Unite, Steward, and Evaluate. The gap it found, a collaboration lifecycle run on email and disconnected tools with no shared record across the organizations involved, is the problem our Helikon platform was built to close.

How to cite it

Chicago (author-date) Flowers, Andrew T., and Rebecca Roadman. 2024. "Catalyzing Strategic Partnerships: Digital Transformation of University-Industry Collaborations for Synchronized Innovation." Paper presented at the R&D Management Conference 2024, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden, June 17-19.

APA Flowers, A. T., & Roadman, R. (2024, June 17-19). Catalyzing strategic partnerships: Digital transformation of university-industry collaborations for synchronized innovation [Conference paper]. R&D Management Conference 2024, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden.

BibTeX

@inproceedings{flowers2024catalyzing,
  author    = {Flowers, Andrew T. and Roadman, Rebecca},
  title     = {Catalyzing Strategic Partnerships: Digital Transformation of University-Industry Collaborations for Synchronized Innovation},
  booktitle = {R\&D Management Conference 2024},
  address   = {Stockholm, Sweden},
  organization = {KTH Royal Institute of Technology},
  year      = {2024},
  month     = jun
}

Related